Springfield grapples with false pet-eating rumours – and real problems

A week after Donald Trump’s comments during a presidential debate brought Springfield, Ohio, into the national spotlight, the city is still working to separate fact from fiction amid the ongoing fallout.

Once the cameras were packed away and the Proud Boys left, Springfield found itself in a fragile state of peace. However, the local environment remains affected by the presence of state troopers, deployed by Ohio Governor Mike DeWine in response to nearly 30 bomb threats aimed at schools and government facilities. Authorities have confirmed that these threats primarily originated from outside the U.S., yet the identities of those responsible remain unknown.

One thing nearly all residents agree on is the falsehood of the rumor that sparked much of the chaos—that Haitians have been capturing and consuming pets.

As we explore Springfield, it presents itself as a typical small Midwestern town, featuring impressive homes from more prosperous eras, a bustling downtown, an art museum, and even a Frank Lloyd Wright-designed residence. However, neighboring areas tell a different story, with crumbling strip malls, boarded-up houses, and pothole-riddled streets.

Springfield’s population had been declining for decades until a few years ago when a significant number of Haitians arrived, drawn by the lower cost of living and available factory jobs. Current estimates suggest that between 12,000 and 20,000 Haitians now reside in a city that once boasted around 60,000 residents, according to the 2020 census.

While some local business owners and residents have welcomed the newcomers, others have raised concerns about increasing rents, strains on local schools and hospitals, and dangerous driving. Tensions rose last year after a tragic incident involving a car driven by a Haitian immigrant, which collided with a school bus, resulting in the death of an 11-year-old boy.

Recently, the situation has been exacerbated by outrageous rumors claiming that Haitian immigrants were eating pets. These rumors gained momentum after a YouTube video referenced a second-hand account and a dubious Facebook post. The author of that post later retracted her statements upon realizing they were baseless. Nevertheless, the rumor spread rapidly, fueled by right-wing social media and even catching Trump’s attention during the debate, where he remarked, “In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs. The people that came in, they’re eating the cats.”

In response to the debate, Springfield’s Mayor Rob Rue highlighted the importance of responsible public discourse, emphasizing that people need to understand how harmful their words can be to communities. Notably, local police have reported no incidents of pet consumption, yet independent right-wing news outlets have been on the hunt for evidence, even offering rewards for proof of cat abductions, though nothing has been substantiated.

Despite the absence of evidence supporting these unfounded claims, Trump’s comments have heightened tensions between the Haitian community and local residents. At a recent rally, Trump announced plans to visit Springfield soon, stating, “I’m going to go there in the next two weeks.”

Mayor Rue expressed apprehension over a potential Trump rally, indicating it would strain local resources significantly. “It’d be fine with me if they decided not to make that visit,” he noted during a news conference.